Women who drink once in a while may have an easier time staying slim
than women who do not drink at all, according to a recent US study.
Women
who drank red wine gained the least weight overall, and some of the
women who did not drink went on to become overweight or obese 12 years
after the study began.
All in all, women who drank between one
and two glasses of beer, wine, or spirits a day were up to 30% less
likely than teetotallers to become overweight or obese.
Researchers
said that women who already drank in moderation should be encouraged by
the finding, but that people should not take up drinking in order to
lose weight.
For the study, researchers originally quizzed more
than 19,000 women, all older than 39, none of whom were overweight or
obese when the study began.
In the initial questionnaire, some
40% of the women reported not drinking at all, 33% said that they had
about two drinks a week, 20% said they had about one drink a day, 6%
said two drinks a day, and 3% drank more than two drinks a day.
When
the researchers polled each of the women a second time, after an
average of 13 years, they found that most of the women had gained some
weight.
Even when the researchers adjusted their calculations for age
differences, race, total calorie intake, activity level, and tobacco
use, they found that the women in the study who did not drink at all
were the most likely to gain weight.
Other studies have linked moderate alcohol use to limiting weight gain.
In
a large health survey done in 2005, researchers found that people of
both sexes who drank in moderation were thinner, on average.
Binge drinking was associated with increased obesity risk, however.
Ahmed
A. Arif, an associate professor of epidemiology at the University of
North Carolina in the US, who led the study from several years ago,
said that he did not know what biological mechanisms might make people
who drink moderately less likely to be obese.
The researchers
who worked on the present study said that they believed women who drank
alcohol substituted alcohol calories for food calories when they drank.
Catherine
Collins, a dietitian and spokesperson for the British Dietetic
Association, said that she believed it would be a mistake to think that
drinking alcohol helped people lose weight.
She said that the
women who took part in the recent study were not average, and that
being within a normal weight range by age 39 was quite a feat in itself.


